The Player becomes Flumpty’s new best friend, kinda
Having survived both/all three nights, The Player is taken to the first location and beckoned to receive their prize. Upon following Flumpty, they are told that, in order to become Flumpty’s new best friend, they must first kill their old best friend. The Player refuses to do so. Flumpty calmly and collectively reacts by slaughtering both The Player and his best friend, skinning them and removing their arms.